As a geek that might be true for you, but most of us just want
one reliable service, and that seems to be impossible, or at least very difficult, in some parts of the UK.
I'm willing to be shot down on this one, but if something works for me I have a tendency to stick with it. I belong to the school of 'if it ain't broke don't fix it'. I don't like being dictated to by technology companies either, i.e being forced to upgrade or change service just for the sake of it.
Down at the meet at the Winking Man near Leek the other week, for example, those of us stayed behind an extra day all had dreadful phone reception even though everyone was signed up to different phone networks. There was no wifi at all in the vicinity as the pub closes on Mondays & switches the wifi service off, so communication with the rest of the world was pretty much zero.
As for numbers running out because so many people have ditched their PAYG phones, well I'm sure the industry will find a way forward. In fact I'd lay a very large wager that they'll find a way forward!
Going back to the original poster of this thread, who was annoyed at losing 'credit' on their PAYG phone, whether there are network black spots or not is kind of a side issue.
The phone service providers ARE robbing people by taking their pre-paid service away from them if they don't regularly use a PAYG phone.
In fact, this happened to my 84 year old m-i-l not so long ago and could have had adverse consequences. She had a flat tyre on the motorway and pulled over onto the slip road. When she came to use her PAYG phone to call for help she discovered that her £20 credit had disappeared because she only uses the phone for emergencies exactly like the one she was experiencing. Fortunately a nice chap stopped and changed the tyre for her, but what would have happened if he hadn't?! Apply this to lots of other situations, some of which might be far more serious that just a flat tyre!
I have always had a contract mobile phone, so I'm not overly bothered about this issue, but it is quite simply THEFT and Ofcom should be asked to put a stop to it asap. End of.