phillybarbour
Full Member
- Posts
- 7,580
- Likes
- 2,276
Very interesting to read thanks for posting
Some people like picking holes in any and every thing
Cheers
Thanks , Lots to consider there .
In these days of deisel particle filters , is it a bad idea to run your engine on idle to charge your batteries , except in an emergency..... ?
Yes, its a bad idea. I would only do it in an emergency.
I thought Diesel Particulate Filters were easy to clean out by getting the exhaust system hot, usually a blast down the Motorway or up a large hill in a low gear.
so I invested in a couple of leads and now have them connected in parallel, so they charge and discharge together.
I was thinking of the solar route but your article has made me thing twice so will go down the suck it and see route instead.
400w of solar, diesel airtop 3500, 3.5kw truma gas, all led lights, a 300w inverter for tv and laptop charging, a 20a rapid charger and 3x 110ah batteries. (I can watch discharge values and charge values on 2x digital power meters).
To be honest, the solar is pretty much useless in winter unless the sun is shining and the one tilting 80w panel gives more power than the other 320w !
In summer its way over specked and the batteries are fully charged very early morning, so I end up running the fridge on solar all day.
(nearly 50kg of weight on the roof)
conclusion- one 80 to120w tilting panel is about the best charge to weight option and most efficient for all year use.
Alternator split charging - start the engine and a burst of amps runs through to the leisure batteries dependant on their state of charge, but this does tail off to 6a very quickly just as it does on the engine battery of every vehicle.
conclusion - you do have to drive for hours to top up the leisures at 6a and it seems pretty pointless idling the engine to do so unless in an emergency with flat leisures.
Airtop diesel heating - Boy does this use power ! - on full chat 3ah dropping to 1ah when up to temperature , but the big problem is the amount of power the glow plug uses to start and stop it ( 6 to 20 amps )
Advantages - convenient being able to buy and use red diesel and instant heat .
Truma blown gas - hot water and heating (1 to 2.5 ah )
Advantage - uses less than half the power of a diesel system and costs half the price to run against normal pump diesel (roughly the same against red diesel )
HERE IS THE CRUNCH.
In summer the 3 x 110ah new batteries will happily give over 150ah of useable power but in winter they will only give 60ah of power due to the cold temperature. yes, just 60ah useable from 330ah
conclusion - At a time I need more power I have less than half the power and solar will not perform and all I can expect from a drive or idling is 6ah.
SOLUTION.
Strip off the solar leaving 80 to 120a tilting and use an 8kg 300w tiny silent generator hooked to the 20a battery charger which takes roughly 3 hours to put back the 60ah !
Or maybe reduce your consumption - 60ah per day seems rather high. Maybe ditch the inverter and get a more efficient TV.
At the risk of being 'grandmothers and eggs' when you connected the two batteries in parallel make sure you drawn power from the pair taking the Negative from one battery and the Positive from the other (if possible) ... it helps even out the wear on them.