I have been suffering from the same problem. Very stiff and lumpy in operation. Tried lubrication which didn't really solve the problem. Mine is a C2 which is similar to yours. At times Joan had difficulty in operating the valve. We have two cassettes and it is the same with both. The cassettes open easily by hand when out of the toilet.
Ours had now gone sloppy in operation and is still lumpy. This happened in early November as we arrived in Spain and has been in daily use since.
This may help
C2 - C3 - C4
Have a look at the pdf for the mechanism
John