Can I legally have a drink

Mrs Mossy

Full Member
Posts
563
Likes
1,857
A common question on our forums is “Can I legally have a drink in my motorhome when I’m in a public place. Hardly surprising that this question is asked a lot because more than ever, motorhomers are parking in places other than campsites. We have schemes like ********* which offer a lot of pub stopovers, and there are plenty of other directories and maps, such as Funster Keith’s map which he lists over 900 pubs that allow night-stops and diligently keeps it updated.
If you drink more than the drive limit in your motorhome in a “public Place”, then you run a real risk of being found to be “Drunk In Charge” This is an offence on a par with “Drink Driving” and carries similar fines, endorsements and disqualifications.

The offence of being Drunk in Charge is committed if:

“a person is in charge of any motor vehicle on a road or other public place after consuming so much alcohol that the proportion of it in his breath, blood or urine exceeds the prescribed limit he is guilty of an offence”

Questioning the Association of Chief Police Officers and asking if there is any dispensation at all for motorhomers and you’ll get no advice other than the definition above being repeated. So that’s it. Go over the limit in your motorhome in a public place and whether you intend to drive or not you are committing the offence of Drunk in Charge.

Let’s deal with the public place aspect first. If you are pitched in pub car park while the pub is open, then you are very likely in a public place. When the pub closes, this becomes a grey area as to whether it’s public and might depend upon legal interpretation. However, you should assume that most places that invite us to pitch are more “public” than we might imagine.

Now let’s take the person in charge aspect. Essentially there is no legal definition for the term “in charge” so each case will depend on the exact circumstances you find yourself in. The Police National Legal Database describes ‘In Charge’ like this:-

“There is no hard and fast rule or strict test for what constitutes ‘in charge’ for the purposes of being in charge of a vehicle whilst under the influence of drink or drugs under section 4 and being in charge of a vehicle whilst over the prescribed limit under section 5 of the 1988 Act. However, a close connection between the defendant and control of the vehicle is required. That connection may be evidenced by the defendants position in relation to the car, his actions, possession of a key which fits the ignition, his intentions as regards control of the vehicle and the position of anyone else in, at or near the vehicle.”

You have a legal defence. if you can show that there was no likelihood of you driving your vehicle whilst you remained in excess of the prescribed limit or unfit. However, this is for you to prove rather than the Police to disprove.

If you are drunk and sat in the driving seat with the motorhome keys on your person or in the ignition. You are very likely to be charged. If you are charged your defence will be based upon the balance of probabilities that you were not intending to drive.

Plenty of things that you do might indicate that you had no intention of driving. If you have booked/paid for a night, you are in your pyjamas, your silver screens are in place, you are on levelling blocks, your bedroom slide is extended, your steadies wound down, your driving seat swivelled inward ect. All these things indicate that your intention was to sleep and not drive.

However even then, if you are off-your-face at 1 am and admit that you are going to hit the road at 7 am, the police officer might calculate that even though you are in your pyjamas, you will still be over at 7 am and might arrest you. Remember your defence is that you do not intend to drive, and there is no likelihood of you driving until you are sober to do so.

Best practice

When you are parked in a public place wherever there is a chance you might be moved on. Such places include lay-bys, deserted car parks, etc. You should never be over the limit. The risk of suddenly becoming Drunk In Charge or Driving Under the Influence are high.

If you are parking in a place like a pub car-park, assume it is public and build your defence before you have had a drink. If after you have been drinking you decide that you are parked in the wrong place or facing the wrong way, you only have to be seen in that seat, and you risk arrest. Similarly, if you sit in the drivers seat to spin the seat around, or start the engine to charge batteries, etc. If you get the wrong copper no matter what your protestations you might rightly be charged, your statutory defence comes long afterwards with you having to prove your defence to a magistrate.

Things you can do to ensure you are not arrested.

Make sure the landlord knows your intention to sleep in the car park.
Ensure the motorhome is parked in the right place and not causing any obstructions before you have a drink.
Put your silver-screens in the windscreen (internally will do)
If you use a third party steering lock, pop it on.
If you have a slide-out, put it out
Put jacks or steadies down
Never have the keys in or anywhere near the ignition
If you have a safe, put the keys in it
Never sit in the driving seat unless it is spun around
Remember, if you are over the limit, and deemed to be in charge then you may well be technically guilty. However if you make it really obvious that you have no intention of driving then, a reasonable police officer will not be interested in you and even if they have occasion to speak to you will readily accept you are no danger to yourself or anyone else and have no intention of driving.
 
likely intention and environment I.e
motorhomes have beds and heating unlike a mini

channa
 
likely intention and environment I.e
motorhomes have beds and heating unlike a mini

channa

we always after getting set up, settle down with our drinks, they cant move you on if you have had a drink, if they do it there fault
 
I put this very question to a 'bobby' and he said that if it appears you have no intention of driving, seats turned around, keys tucked away, blinds closed etc, he nor his colleagues would arrest for drink driving. Not definitive, there are plenty of 4rsehole coppers out there but I would have a drink and feel quite safe in doing so.
What would make it a really tricky situation is: if a bunch of yobbo's started stoning your MH and threatening to kill you, you could phone the police and wait a couple of hours for them to respond or you could hightail it out of there. Very tricky.
 
I have never read a thread on this subject that is able to provide anything other than a grey response, as is done here.

Although, I have chatted with many people who have black or white opinions, they are generally nothing other than personal opinions and will hold no weight when Plod comes a Knocking.

This is why 'Mrs M' rerunning it occasionally is such a great idea, to re-enforce that it is such a grey area and 'Camper Beware' We have an ever growing membership and one newbie licence saved, it worth the repetition.

I was also wondering if it and other commonly repeated basics, could be included in a dedicated section 'Newbie News' Maybe this section could be closed to new posts by general members but allow the 'Knights of the Wild Camping Forum' to add them, thus keeping it free from Smoke, Mirrors and the Tennis Match of differing opinions that can, all to soon, bury a 'Golden Nugget' in a mountain of {add to comments}

The 'Knights of the Wild Camping Forum' can then use their special powers to spot stuff useful to a newbie and 'Cut n Paste' it into the aforementioned dedicated section.

Thoughts?
 
A common suggestion for this situation is to have what is VW Cool Hippy Dudes get ... A 'Surf' key. :banana:
So a basic key cut for the locks but without the immobiliser chip in or programmed. Hide the 'real' key and have that visible and you can demonstrate that even if you were minded to you could not start the engine and drive away.
If you want to go really belts and braces, leave the real key behind the bar in the pub to collect next morning if in a pub carpark.
In a proper public place you could claim to be broken down as well and say assistance coming in morning or calling garage for advice in morning.
 
I put this very question to a 'bobby' and he said that if it appears you have no intention of driving, seats turned around, keys tucked away, blinds closed etc, he nor his colleagues would arrest for drink driving. Not definitive, there are plenty of 4rsehole coppers out there but I would have a drink and feel quite safe in doing so.
What would make it a really tricky situation is: if a bunch of yobbo's started stoning your MH and threatening to kill you, you could phone the police and wait a couple of hours for them to respond or you could hightail it out of there. Very tricky.

I asked a serving officer a similar question and got pretty much the same response as I mentioned intention is the acid question

Last part of your sentence I highlighted you would be charged for being over the prescribed limit there is no statutory defence which is what people are talking about parked up in the motorhome ( separate offence which I guess you know)

If for example you were to be asked to move by a police officer and are over the limit being asked is not a defence so the same would apply (get them to shift it)

I don't know anyone with a motorhome charged for DIC or the I know a bloke stories similar to being gassed.

channa
 
A common suggestion for this situation is to have what is VW Cool Hippy Dudes get ... A 'Surf' key. :banana:
So a basic key cut for the locks but without the immobiliser chip in or programmed. Hide the 'real' key and have that visible and you can demonstrate that even if you were minded to you could not start the engine and drive away.
If you want to go really belts and braces, leave the real key behind the bar in the pub to collect next morning if in a pub carpark.
In a proper public place you could claim to be broken down as well and say assistance coming in morning or calling garage for advice in morning.

Exactly all ideas of possible intent to drive off removed

Channa
 
Any one thinking of drinking over here had better be sure the keys are with someone else or you will get done.
I had a uncle done in bangor co down man years back as he walked from a club and stopped with keys in pocket even though car was in next street.
Even if a car is outside your house on public rd and you are in the house drunk with keys they will also have you.
Down south in republic up until a few years back most folk drove half pissed,things have changed and if the garda stop you they may well kick ten bells out of you and im not joking.
 
In Spain no you can.t if you have van keys near by when i was pull on this i just said that my wife has the keys in her bag and she has gone shopping, lucky they never came back because i was on my own on the beach fishing
 
Any one thinking of drinking over here had better be sure the keys are with someone else or you will get done.
I had a uncle done in bangor co down man years back as he walked from a club and stopped with keys in pocket even though car was in next street.
Even if a car is outside your house on public rd and you are in the house drunk with keys they will also have you.
Down south in republic up until a few years back most folk drove half pissed,things have changed and if the garda stop you they may well kick ten bells out of you and im not joking.

Last time I was in Ireland (think 2007 or 2008?), Somewhere in the countryside around the west coast it was and was in the pub at a wake (was over for a funeral). Was debating whether to drive the two miles back to the house in the wreck of the hire car I had, and the fella sitting next to me said sure, you'll have no worries. Turned out he was a guard! :D

(Fine drive except ripped the underbelly pan off the Stilo on the gravel roads. Man, it made some noise doing that!)
(Oh, and wasn't actually drunk anyway. Maybe 2 pints, but I am cautious)
 
I asked a serving officer a similar question and got pretty much the same response as I mentioned intention is the acid question

Last part of your sentence I highlighted you would be charged for being over the prescribed limit there is no statutory defence which is what people are talking about parked up in the motorhome ( separate offence which I guess you know)

If for example you were to be asked to move by a police officer and are over the limit being asked is not a defence so the same would apply (get them to shift it)

I don't know anyone with a motorhome charged for DIC or the I know a bloke stories similar to being gassed.

channa

I agree regarding your comment on the highlighted sentence but the conundrum for me would be, do I risk getting the MH wrecked or being physically attacked by the yobs or do I drive off and risk getting stopped by the police. Of course, not being over the limit when in a place as has been described above is the sensible option. However, should the attack scenario arise whilst being over the limit, then getting away from immediate danger would probably be the first impulse for many, without any thought of the trouble ahead should the police stop you.

Confronting a gang of yobs who may well be fuelled up on drink or drugs is definitely not on my advice list, I have read of too many cases where it has turned out very badly for the confronter. If I was 6' 8" 30 years old and built like the proverbial bog house then I might think differently but still very risky imo.
 
Last time I was in Ireland (think 2007 or 2008?), Somewhere in the countryside around the west coast it was and was in the pub at a wake (was over for a funeral). Was debating whether to drive the two miles back to the house in the wreck of the hire car I had, and the fella sitting next to me said sure, you'll have no worries. Turned out he was a guard! :D

(Fine drive except ripped the underbelly pan off the Stilo on the gravel roads. Man, it made some noise doing that!)
(Oh, and wasn't actually drunk anyway. Maybe 2 pints, but I am cautious)

Yep used to be like that but things have moved on due to the high rate of rd accidents due to the lunatic soup.
I was stopped once after having one pint and was just below lmit so just stopped drinking as my licence is a must.
 
I have never read a thread on this subject that is able to provide anything other than a grey response, as is done here.

Although, I have chatted with many people who have black or white opinions, they are generally nothing other than personal opinions and will hold no weight when Plod comes a Knocking.

This is why 'Mrs M' rerunning it occasionally is such a great idea, to re-enforce that it is such a grey area and 'Camper Beware' We have an ever growing membership and one newbie licence saved, it worth the repetition.

I was also wondering if it and other commonly repeated basics, could be included in a dedicated section 'Newbie News' Maybe this section could be closed to new posts by general members but allow the 'Knights of the Wild Camping Forum' to add them, thus keeping it free from Smoke, Mirrors and the Tennis Match of differing opinions that can, all to soon, bury a 'Golden Nugget' in a mountain of {add to comments}

The 'Knights of the Wild Camping Forum' can then use their special powers to spot stuff useful to a newbie and 'Cut n Paste' it into the aforementioned dedicated section.

Thoughts?

Gets the post count up too !
 
I put this very question to a 'bobby' and he said that if it appears you have no intention of driving, seats turned around, keys tucked away, blinds closed etc, he nor his colleagues would arrest for drink driving. Not definitive, there are plenty of 4rsehole coppers out there but I would have a drink and feel quite safe in doing so.
What would make it a really tricky situation is: if a bunch of yobbo's started stoning your MH and threatening to kill you, you could phone the police and wait a couple of hours for them to respond or you could hightail it out of there. Very tricky.
Well if a bad cop would arrest you in the situation you describe there are 2 issues here. one is that the good cops did not do their job and arrest you for drinking whilst in charge of a motor vehicle, and the bad cop did his duty and arrested you, and 2 it would make your good cops corrupt wouldn't it, as the law is the law whatever it is and must be upheld, we can not be allowed to pick out the bits we like and disregard the bits we do not, that would lead to anarchy, Common sense would suggest that if camping/parked in anything less than a recognised camping place one should not drink alcohol in excess of what the law requires for driving a motor vehicle, as one can never be sure that one will not be required to move the vehicle. i. e. drive it?
 
Pub car park

...why should anyone be asked to move from the bottom end of a pub car park ? Also, are you not "off the public highways" in a pub car park ? Also, does anyone know of anybody being dragged out of Moho in their pj's....breathalized and chucked in a cell for the night (in England) ?? Maja
 
...why should anyone be asked to move from the bottom end of a pub car park ? Also, are you not "off the public highways" in a pub car park ? Also, does anyone know of anybody being dragged out of Moho in their pj's....breathalized and chucked in a cell for the night (in England) ?? Maja

This nonsense comes up every now and then , similar to the gassing threads . Wherever I park up I usually have a glass of wine when I have no intention of moving on . On 2 separate occasions [Scotland and England] I have had a knock from police . Once in Musselburgh , think somebody from flats opposite had complained . Once somewhere in Yorkshire , friendly check all was ok . Both occasions I had settled down with a glass of wine . Police had no interest . I did offer them a glass , not so many years ago my offer would have been accepted .
 
Even if a car is outside your house on public rd and you are in the house drunk with keys they will also have you.

Hmmmmm .. :rolleyes2:

Now that does sound a bit far fetched .. I take my keys to bed at night so they could storm in and demand that I take a breathalyser test otherwise how the hell are they going to know. I would have thought that on a Friday night they could walk down any street and arrest just about everyone who has his car parked outside his house

..
 
Last edited:
Hmmmmm .. :rolleyes2:

Now that does sound a bit far fetched .. I take my keys to bed at night so they could storm in and demand that I take a breathalyser test otherwise how the hell are they going to know. I would have thought that on a Friday night they could walk down any street and arrest just about everyone who has his car parked outside his house

..

....well glad someone has sense !! With Trevs theory everyone would be locked up if car on road and them pissed in house LOL !! How ridiculous !!! Trev...yer losing it !! Maja
 

Users who viewed this discussion (Total:0)

Back
Top